Mandatory Vaccinations – Government overreaching?

With the HPV vaccinations debate trying to grab media attention, I thought I’d offer a voice of reason to the arguments.

At first glance, any government requirement on the individual seems heavy handed – particularly when it involves our bodies.

So, when the government tells us we must get Measles vaccinations to attend school or get Small Pox vaccinations, are they getting overly involved in our freedoms over our own bodies?

The short simple answer is yes.

Life is not simple.

Small Pox doesn’t exist in any significant numbers today because the state governments required that everyone be vaccinated and people complained about the heavy handedness of those requirements too. The government isn’t inoculating one person; they are inoculating the population as a whole. It is the government’s job to protect the health of the population. In the case of vaccines, preventing disease is certainly part of that.

While the government cannot and should not step into each individuals choices of lifestyle that could lead to acquiring medical ailments, they certainly should step in when those choices of lifestyles could result in spreading those ailments to a larger portion of the population.

Communicable diseases, when vaccination is possible, no matter how they are communicated, should be eradicated through vaccination in every case where it is possible to do so. Again, in these cases, the government isn’t violating the individual; it is inoculating the populace as a whole.

To date, the only medical study that said that vaccinations had significant adverse side effects was, as the author later admitted, a fabrication for profit. No, measles vaccine doesn’t cause autism. While there will always be the odd individual here and there who will have an allergy or pre-existing condition incompatible with the vaccine, on the whole, they save thousands more lives than they harm.

Even with something like HPV, death from HPV caused cancer occurs far more often than any significantly inconvenient side effect of the vaccine. I don’t count needle pricks as an inconvenient side effect. And the HPV vaccine policies are not sexist. Women are not the only people who can catch HPV, but they are the ones most likely to die from it (I’m not a doctor, but I’m fairly sure men can’t get cervical cancer)–and women are the only ones we have a vaccine for.


About wilogden

Wil Ogden was destined to be a wastrel but thwarted fate. During his second junior year in high school he discovered he had a muse and a talent for writing. Despite taking almost a decade to complete a bachelor's degree by changing majors eleven times, he managed to grow up. Along the way he worked as a blacksmith, a record store manager, a candy store manager, too many years in food service, a four year stint in the USAF, and finally settled down into Information Technology, which he uses to pay the bills and support his family of himself, his wife, son, seven daughters, two dogs, three cats, six chickens, a snake, a ferret and two parakeets.

Posted on September 17, 2011, in Tripe. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: